Courtney Leopold/Sylvia Fishman Played By Jenny McCarthy

You know there’s something wrong when a fictional character has two different full names. Courtney Leopold/Sylvia Fishman is a former professional con-artist whose deceiving skills have never stopped being part of her life. She appears in seasons 5, 8, and 9, and she’s at one point the show’s main antagonist.

Unlike Fishman, Jenny McCarthy’s acting/modeling skills are no scam. The gorgeous blonde from Illinois made a name for herself by posing in magazines and appearing in the movies Dirty Love, and John Tucker Must Die. In recent years, she’s been working as a judge on the celebrity game show The Masked Singer.